Colorado New Home Choices

Colorado New Home Choices

Negative Pressure Nightmare

A technician working in a new 200-unit Fort Collins apartment project encountered heat spilling into one apartment from its water heater flue. Fortunately, he had recently attended City-sponsored training on combustion safety problems. Yet he was a self-proclaimed “non-believer” who felt the trainers had exaggerated potential health and safety problems. Nonetheless, when he encountered this problem, he hired one of the trainers for a site visit. The diagnosis: a major combustion safety hazard.

The apartments were stacked: the ground-floor units were built over vented crawl spaces; the upper units had vented attics above. Furnaces were located in closets in the apartments. Leaky supply ducts running through the crawl spaces and attics were the root cause of the problem. The heating distribution system was no longer a closed loop. Each time the furnace came on, some warm air delivered through supply ducts was blown into the crawl space or the attic. This meant the single return, located right at the furnace, was trying to draw more air from the apartment than the supply ducts delivered; as a result, the apartment became depressurized. Whenever any one of the seven supply registers was closed by occupants, negative pressure within the home grew even stronger, strong enough to overpower the water heater’s draft and continuously backdraft all combustion byproducts. Once re-burned by the water heater, those byproducts can create carbon monoxide, which can then be drawn into the furnace and recirculated within the living space.

Health complaints by residents in other apartments suggested this problem was likely present in other units as well.

Possible fixes, some addressing only the symptoms, others going after the root causes:

  • Seal all crawl space and attic ductwork with mastic to reduce supply leakage; then test the resulting pressure balance.
  • Install a carbon monoxide detector in every unit.
  • Install a spillage sensor on each water heater to shut off operation whenever spillage occurs.
  • Remodel all crawl spaces to be “warm” (unvented) designs and remove attic venting, so that any air leaks from supply ducts stay within the home.
  • Replace all atmospherically vented water heaters with sealed-combustion models.

Within 48 hours of the tests, management began the process of installing a carbon monoxide detector in each apartment unit.


Last Updated: 08/21/2003